Teaching toddlers in Sunday school is a steady, joy-filled responsibility.
Their hands stay active, their minds stay curious, and their hearts respond well to simple, meaningful activities.
Crafts offer a clear way to support that growth. When little ones create something with purpose, they remember the story with clarity and delight.
The ideas below are designed for small groups, quick setups, and calm guidance.
You’ll find every project straightforward, engaging, and easy to fit into a short lesson.
These seven crafts bring gentle structure to the classroom and create opportunities for connection, conversation, and faith-centered learning.
Let’s begin.
What Makes a Craft “Engaging” for Toddlers
Toddlers stay focused when the activity matches their natural pace and curiosity.
An engaging craft welcomes their energy and guides it with steady structure. Materials feel comfortable in small hands.
Movements stay simple and clear. Colors remain bright and cheerful. Each step supports learning without rushing or overwhelming.
A strong craft also connects directly to the Bible story.
Toddlers respond well to visuals (sun, water, animals, baskets, trees) elements they recognize immediately.
These familiar shapes anchor the lesson and help them remember what you shared.
Your calm presence brings the craft together. When you demonstrate each step with steady enthusiasm, toddlers follow with confidence.
A peaceful rhythm forms, and the room stays engaged through the entire activity.
Want more craft ideas your kids will adore? Check out my list of irresistible felt craft for kids for fun, hands-on projects!
7 Toddler-Friendly Sunday School Craft Ideas
These crafts are designed to support a smooth Sunday school rhythm.
Each one highlights a clear Bible truth, uses cheerful materials toddlers enjoy, and invites steady, hands-on participation.
1. “God Made the Animals” Collage
Genesis 1:24–25 – A simple, tactile way to celebrate God’s creation.
Toddlers love soft textures and familiar shapes. This cheerful collage gives them an easy way to explore the creation story by placing animals God made on a bright, simple background.
Materials:
- Large sheet of construction paper
- Pre-cut soft foam animal shapes (or paper shapes)
- Glue sticks
- Green paper strips (grass)
- Cotton balls (optional clouds)
Steps:
- Give each toddler a sheet of construction paper.
- Help them glue on “grass” at the bottom.
- Let them place animal shapes wherever they’d like.
- Add cotton clouds if you want a gentle sky detail.
Teaching moment:
As they place each animal, share a simple line: “God made all the animals. God made them good.”
This keeps the craft anchored to the creation story with clear, toddler-friendly language.
For more ways to keep little ones engaged indoors, especially during chilly days, try cozy winter indoor sensory play ideas.
2. Noah’s Ark Animal Stick Puppets
Genesis 6–9 – Encourages simple storytelling and cheerful interaction with the Bible story.
Toddlers enjoy holding small objects and moving them around with intention.
Animal stick puppets support that interest and create space for gentle, guided storytelling.
Just like interactive games for teaching the 10 commandments, these puppets let children explore important Bible lessons through hands-on play.
The craft stays simple, and the finished puppets offer an easy way to repeat the lesson through play.
Materials:
- Craft sticks
- Pre-cut animal shapes (paper or foam)
- Washable glue
- Small animal stickers (optional)
- Short cardboard strip as a “mini ark” base (optional)
Steps:
- Help toddlers glue each animal shape onto a craft stick.
- Add simple stickers or small details as they choose.
- Set out a short cardboard strip to represent the ark and let them “bring the animals aboard.”
Teaching moment:
As they place each puppet, share this simple reminder: “God cares for every creature. God cares for us too.” This steady message keeps the activity connected to the heart of the story.
3. Baby Moses Basket Craft
Exodus 2 – A gentle visual that highlights God’s steady protection and care.
Toddlers enjoy placing objects into containers, and this simple motion matches the heart of the story.
The craft gives them a calm, hands-on way to understand how Baby Moses rested safely in the basket.
The activity stays structured, cheerful, and easy to guide.
Materials:
- Small paper cup or mini paper bowl (as the basket)
- Brown or tan paper strips for “weaving”
- Glue
- Pre-cut paper “Baby Moses” figure
- Blue construction paper (optional water background)
Steps:
- Invite toddlers to glue paper strips around the cup or bowl to create a woven look.
- Add the small paper Baby Moses figure inside the basket.
- If using blue paper, place the basket on it to represent the riverbank.
Teaching moment:
As they gently place Baby Moses inside the basket, share a steady reminder: “God keeps us safe and guides us with love.” This anchors the craft in the message of the story.
For more hands-on Bible activities, see exciting walls of Jericho crafts for kids.
4. David’s Harp Music Shaker
1 Samuel 16 – Sound, rhythm, and joyful praise made simple for little hands.
Toddlers enjoy rhythm and movement. This craft gives them a calm, constructive way to create sound while connecting to David’s gift of music.
The shaker is easy to hold, simple to make, and encourages cheerful participation during songs or short praise moments.
Materials:
- Two sturdy paper plates
- A small handful of dry beans or rice
- Washable markers or crayons
- Stapler or tape
- Ribbon or yarn (optional for a handle)
Steps:
- Invite toddlers to decorate the back sides of both plates with bright, cheerful colors.
- Place a small amount of beans or rice between the plates.
- Staple or tape the edges securely.
- Add a ribbon loop if you’d like a simple handle.
Teaching moment:
As they shake the finished craft, remind them: “We can praise God with music. Every joyful sound matters.” This keeps the activity centered on worship in a way toddlers understand.
For more festive, hands-on activities, see joyful Christmas Christian crafts for kids.
5. Daniel and the Lions’ Den Lion Mask
Daniel 6 – A playful way for toddlers to explore courage and God’s steady presence.
Toddlers enjoy wearing simple masks and exploring expression.
This craft gives them a clear, hands-on way to participate in the story. The motions stay easy, and the finished mask encourages cheerful reenactment.
Materials:
- Paper plate
- Yellow and orange paper strips (mane)
- Glue
- Pre-cut eye openings
- Craft stick (optional handle)
Steps:
- Help toddlers glue the paper strips around the edge of the plate to form a bright, simple mane.
- Hold the plate up to ensure the eye openings align comfortably.
- Add a craft stick to the bottom if you prefer a handheld mask.
Teaching moment:
As they hold up their lion masks, share: “God stays with us and gives us courage.” This keeps the focus steady and supportive.
For more simple, budget-friendly activities, see easy Sunday school crafts on a budget.
6. God’s Promise Rainbow Craft
Genesis 9 – A joyful reminder that God keeps His promises.
Toddlers are naturally drawn to color and simple repetition.
This bright rainbow craft gives them a calm, hands-on way to celebrate God’s promise after the flood.
Materials:
- Half paper plate (for the rainbow base)
- Strips of colored paper (red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple)
- Cotton balls (for clouds)
- Glue
Steps:
- Hand out half paper plates to each toddler.
- Help them glue the colored strips in order across the plate.
- Add cotton balls at each end for clouds.
- Write a short reminder across the back: “God keeps His promises.”
Teaching moment:
As they glue, say: “God placed a rainbow in the sky to remind us of His love and promises.” The cheerful colors keep toddlers engaged while connecting the craft to a hopeful message.
7. Jesus Loves Me Heart Bracelet
John 15:12 – A sweet reminder of Jesus’ love and kindness.
This easy threading craft strengthens fine motor skills while helping toddlers learn about love and friendship in a tactile way.
Materials:
- Pipe cleaners
- Large pony beads in bright colors
- Small paper or foam hearts (optional for decoration)
Steps:
- Give each child a pipe cleaner and a few beads.
- Help them slide the beads on, naming colors as they go.
- Twist the ends into a circle to form a bracelet.
- Add a small paper heart with “Jesus loves me” written on it, if desired.
Teaching moment:
As they work, repeat together: “Jesus loves me, and I can show love too.” This simple rhythm keeps the message joyful and easy to remember.
Tips for Leading Crafts With Toddlers in Sunday School
Leading toddlers through a craft becomes smoother when the environment feels calm, structured, and welcoming. A few simple habits create that stability and help the entire group stay engaged.
Prepare materials in advance. Set out everything before the class begins – glue, shapes, stickers, and pre-cut pieces. A ready table supports a peaceful start and gives toddlers confidence as they begin.
Demonstrate each step with clarity. Toddlers follow your motions more than your words. Show the first step slowly, then invite them to try. This steady rhythm keeps their attention focused on the task.
Offer warm encouragement. Celebrate their effort with positive, specific words. A simple affirmation – “You placed that so carefully” – guides them and strengthens their focus.
Keep transitions smooth. Move from the story to the craft with calm enthusiasm. Let them know what’s next and what to expect. This clear structure supports a steady flow in the classroom.
End with a short, cheerful prayer. Close the craft by thanking God for creativity, learning, and the Bible story. This anchors the activity in faith and brings gentle closure to the moment.
For more seasonal, hands-on Bible activities, see faith-filled fall crafts perfect for Sunday school.
Bring These Simple Crafts Into Your Sunday School Routine
These toddler-friendly crafts offer structure, clarity, and cheerful learning throughout the lesson.
When you introduce crafts like these with steady guidance, toddlers stay engaged and confident from start to finish.
If you try any of these ideas in your own classroom, I’d love to hear how they went.
Share your experience in the comments below!
FAQs
How long should each craft take with toddlers?
Most crafts take 5–10 minutes, depending on the group’s pace. Choose one clear goal for each project to keep the activity smooth and focused.
What’s the best way to manage glue and small pieces?
Place a small amount of glue on individual trays or lids. Set out only the pieces needed for each step. This keeps the workspace tidy and helps toddlers stay centered on the craft.
How many helpers do I need for a toddler craft session?
One adult for every 3–4 toddlers works well. Extra hands ensure everyone receives steady support during gluing, sticking, and simple assembly.
Should I prep all the cutting ahead of time?
Yes. Pre-cut shapes keep the experience peaceful and safe. Toddlers can participate fully with steps like pressing, placing, sorting, and decorating.
What’s a good way to store finished crafts?
Use labeled folders or shallow baskets where toddlers can place their project when completed. This keeps the table clear and makes pickup easy for parents.
